Google Search isn't dying... it's eating your website

James Banks standng against a white background wearing a black t-shirt with a white Rankmax company logo on it
By
James Banks
•
Published on
November 2, 2026
You are here:
Home
»
Videos
»
Google Search isn't dying... it's eating your website

c_i2KHnqpwM

Alphabet says Google search queries are growing at their fastest rate in five years, but when an AI summary appears, fewer people click through to a website. The pages that still earn the click give people something a summary can't produce on its own: verifiable results, original data and an author who shows why they know the subject. That is the content we built for one B2B client, where search went from bringing in about 4 consultation bookings a month to a peak of about 40. AI Overviews and AI Mode often pick different sources too, so it is worth tracking the two separately.

Transcript

Google's five-year high

James Banks: In its results for the third quarter of 2026, Alphabet, the company that owns Google, says search queries are growing at the fastest rate in five years. Google's search revenue was up 12 per cent on last year, to 63 billion US dollars in a single quarter. And the CEO of Google and Alphabet, Sundar Pichai, says its AI investments are driving search query growth. That's great news for Google.

But the Pew Research Center, a non-partisan American research organisation, tracked how real people use Google. When an AI summary appeared, people clicked a regular search result on 8 per cent of visits. Without one, it was 15 per cent. And the links inside the AI summary itself? People clicked those on just 1 per cent of visits.

It's like a movie trailer that shows you the entire film. Why would anyone buy a ticket? So Google Search is very much alive, and it's hungry. Your website is on the menu.

Now, AI still needs websites to read. So what kind of page still earns the click? Google's Head of Search gave us a clue, and I'll show you what our client's AI-selected pages had in common. Stick around. This is the AI SEO Report.

The old deal

Under the old deal, you let Google read your entire website for free, and Google sends you visitors. You then greet them with three pop-ups and a cookie banner.

Then Google launched AI Overviews, the AI summaries at the top of the results page, and the deal quietly changed. You give Google the content, and Google gives everyone the answer.

Chartbeat, an analytics company that measures traffic for news and media sites, says Google Search made up roughly 9 per cent of pageviews across its publishers in July 2024. By July 2026, it was down to 5 per cent. It's a bit like a shopping centre bragging about record crowds while the shops inside get fewer customers.

To be fair, Google admits some of this. In August 2025, Google's Head of Search, Liz Reid, published a blog post called "AI in Search: Driving more queries and higher quality clicks". In it, Google says that for a quick question, like when the next full moon is, people may be satisfied with the answer and not click. Honestly, fair enough. Nobody needs a 3,000-word blog post about the moon that starts with the author's childhood.

The same post says total organic clicks are relatively stable, and that the clicks Google sends are now higher quality, meaning people don't bounce straight back. Finally... artisanal, small-batch, handmade clicks. The post didn't share the data behind that, though.

Google's CEO has been talking up the numbers too. At Google's developer conference in May, Sundar Pichai said AI Overviews has over 2.5 billion monthly active users. But using something isn't the same as loving it. Millions of people use the self-checkout at the supermarket, mostly because every other lane is closed.

One person on the social platform X posted how to get rid of AI Overviews, and it had over 40,000 likes when we checked. At this point, that feature request is starting to look like a petition.

When AI gets it wrong

And when Google's AI gets something wrong, that wrong answer can sit above the ordinary results. In Germany, an AI Overview wrongly linked two Munich publishers to subscription traps and fraudulent schemes. According to DW, Germany's international broadcaster, it invented connections that did not exist.

Google's defence included the argument that users know AI-generated information should not be trusted blindly. The Munich court ruled that Google can be held directly liable for what its AI Overview says. It ordered Google to stop spreading the false claims and to pay 80 per cent of the legal costs. Google said it would appeal.

Somewhere, a Google lawyer is asking Google's AI chatbot, Gemini, for a second opinion.

Follow the money

So how is Google's search revenue up 12 per cent while publishers lose clicks? Ads. The cash register seems to be coping. An ad click pays Google, while an ordinary result click gives your site a visitor. Google gets a payment, and you get a maybe. Alphabet's results don't say how much money AI Overviews make on their own. Apparently it has an incognito mode.

Adweek, a publication that covers advertising and media, reports that data from the web analytics company Similarweb shows publishers' paid search budgets have risen 274 per cent in three years. They're paying to buy back the search traffic they used to get for free.

What earns the click

Which brings us back to Liz Reid's blog post. In it, Google says people are more likely to click into content like an in-depth review, an original post, a unique perspective or a thoughtful first-person analysis. So actually having done the thing is now the premium tier. An AI can summarise a review of a burger, but it can't taste the burger.

Here's what that looks like for one of our clients at my agency, Rankmax. Before they started with us in April 2024, search brought this B2B company about 4 consultation bookings a month. And Google hadn't even rolled out AI Overviews to the public yet. We built their content around three things: verifiable client results, original data and consistent author profiles.

By August 2025, that had peaked at about 40 consultation bookings a month. By June 2026, their AI-selected page counts added up to 598 across 4 platforms, with a page counted once per platform. And over those 27 months, the client attributes about $8.7 million in revenue to organic and AI search.

But Google's AI Overviews and AI Mode, its chat-style search, often pick different sources. Babel42, an AI visibility software company, ran the same searches through both on the same day in September, and found they shared only about a third of their sources. It's the same company, but its two bouncers disagree on most of the guest list.

An AI can summarise your results, but it can't invent them. Well, actually, it can. Just ask the court in Munich.

The short version

So here's the short version. One, publish real results and original data. Two, show who wrote it and why they know. Three, track AI Mode and AI Overviews separately.

Has your Google traffic changed? Tell me your industry and what you're seeing in the comments.

This has been the AI SEO Report.

Sources

Sources, accessed 30 October 2026.

Post shown on screen: @KatieRagatha on X, 22 May 2026: https://x.com/KatieRagatha/status/2057622864606695678

Want Help Putting This into Practice?

Rankmax

Everything we publish comes from the same methodology we run for clients every day. Book a discovery call and we will show you how it applies to your business.

45 minute discovery call • No sales pitch • See if we're a fit